BMW’s iDrive 8 infotainment system is not very good


Jul 1, 2022 , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
BMW’s iDrive 8 infotainment system is not very good

Under typical situations, one would be expecting an infotainment system to increase in each way as it transitions from 1 edition to the future. Screens come to be extra responsive, brighter and clearer. The application is tweaked to be much better, and you gain more capabilities than prior to. That is the way it’s intended to work, but BMW’s iDrive 8 does not adhere to this line of imagining.

It hurts me to say this, way too, for I’m conveniently the biggest advocate of iDrive 7 on team listed here at Autoblog. There’s a excellent blend of challenging controls and touchscreen controls for vital vehicle features, and the iDrive knob ties it all jointly in a pleased harmony. The software program by itself is glitch-free, tremendous-speedy to react, and the menu framework can make perception. Most of us on personnel would concur that these are all huge pluses for iDrive 7, including my co-writer for this piece, Senior Editor James Riswick. 

Equally Riswick and I (Highway Exam Editor Zac Palmer) invested individual months in new BMW i4s that feature iDrive 8, and we arrived absent with very similar problems.

Zac’s consider

Sadly, iDrive 8 takes a great deal of iDrive 7’s finest characteristics, then throws them out the window entirely for a alternative that is even worse. What the large bulk of my grievances boil down to is additional complexity to total responsibilities. Anything that could’ve been done with a single faucet in a iDrive 7-equipped BMW now necessitates upwards of a few or more taps. Choose, for instance, the weather controls. BMW taken off all of the difficult weather controls from the heart stack apart from entrance and rear defrost, then tucked them into a new “climate menu.” Temperature regulate stays docked at the bottom of the touchscreen, but if you want to activate your heated seats, it involves a journey by way of the climate menu. The same goes for enthusiast velocity, route of the admirer and nearly anything else you can assume of re: local climate controls. Predictably, it’s a lot more time-consuming to work and much trickier to fiddle with although driving than the wonderful row of buttons BMW employed previously.

Then there’s the BMW’s Dynamic Stability Manage configurations. There is nonetheless a challenging button on the middle console that you can tap to set it into “Sport Traction” method (our beloved for enthusiastic motoring), but as an alternative of just tapping the button, now you need to faucet the button, then tap 2 times extra on the touchscreen to completely activate “Sport Traction.” Why!?

@autoblog BMW’s iDrive 8 infotainment procedure is a step backwards in several approaches
♬ authentic audio – Autoblog

Meanwhile, the new configurations “menu” is a maze of icons. Obtainable by way of the house screen of customizable tiles, the new iDrive menu just appears like the app drawer of anyone else’s cell phone you just picked up. The previously-employed column style menu for auto settings was substantially more fitting for iDrive knob navigation by way of scrolling and rocking. This new scattershot strategy appears to be like it was intended to be navigated exclusively via touchscreen – and hence staring at a thing other than the street for a more time interval of time. Much more time acquiring accustomed to the new composition could enhance matters, and major usage of the voice controls to discover options could enable, too, but which is a perform around. The former framework manufactured excellent perception, and this one is deeply lacking.

At last, and I know James will concur, the full process is just slower! Apps and other goods consider significantly for a longer period to load on the screen. There is occasional lag when touching the display screen, and it’s generally fewer responsive/not as sleek as iDrive 7 is. This could be a result of the software remaining manufacturer new with some kinks that nevertheless need doing the job out, but this is not the course we hope tech to move. The new iDrive 8 should be zippier and easier to use than iDrive 7, but it’s far from that now. — Road Take a look at Editor Zac Palmer

James’ choose

Following about 5 minutes in the BMW i4, I felt like Charleton Heston at the stop of “Earth of the Apes” staring up at the Statue of Liberty. “You blew it up! Damn you!” 

As opposed to Zac, I was in no way specifically enamored of iDrive 7, but at minimum the matter labored well and was effortless enough to determine out (very well, when it obtained its Apple CarPlay connectivity ironed out). It was mainly just an evolution of what iDrive experienced been since around 2010 or so when BMW at last figured out how to make it tolerable. That method just so transpires to be in a car or truck I own, so it’s not like I’m ignorant in the approaches of BMW. 

Possibly way, I concur with Zac, BMW ruined its infotainment program. It is convoluted, bewildering and most damningly for a manufacturer-new process, gradual! Not only do I have to tap-tap-faucet as a result of many menus, I have to wait around even though the laptop or computer provides up the up coming display screen. 

Like Zac, I had a massive beef with the climate controls, but he’s presently gone into that. What I want to speak about is one more fundamental functionality: the radio. Now, indeed, I have an understanding of that a lot of people only hear to their have new music, streamed in some way from their phones or an application, possible via Apple CarPlay and Android Car. Which is great. Men and women however pay attention to the radio, and specially for the reasons of this rant, SiriusXM satellite radio. I’m a single of them – I even use the SiriusXM application consistently at property. 

Now, regardless of whether for satellite or aged-fashioned terrestrial radio, the interfaces in cars to command them have been reliant on person-selected presets (or favorites) due to the fact the 1930s. Usually, you’d just be spinning and spinning and spinning that dial back and forth involving stations. And still! Someway, BMW thinks that is particularly how anyone desires to interact with 470 channels of satellite radio. 

Alternatively of defaulting again to the preset/favorites screen, the damn factor normally dumps you back to the grand list of 470 channels. You are frequently heading back and forth among this default monitor and the favorites list, and then, at the time you’ve actually picked one thing …

Really, you know what? Just look at this: 

@autoblog RANT: BMW has created its new iDrive tech interface even worse, specifically the radio interface
♬ initial audio – Autoblog

The Volkswagen ID.4/GTI tech interface/nightmare has a likewise nonsensical and horrible radio setup. My guess is it was developed by someone who simply cannot understand that persons nonetheless hear to the radio (even if the radio in query is fundamentally just a streaming provider with tracks selected by folks rather than an algorithm) and that their newfangled way was entirely improved. It is not. Even if that is the situation, why not just say “OK Elder Millenial” and give ancients like me the outdated matter they have been employed to? Why hassle reinventing the wheel when you are certain the world has moved onto hoverboards?

Also, I never want to dive into a touchscreen to flip on my heated seat. Especially if that damn screen normally takes for good to load. Just like the ID.4, for that make a difference.

You blew it up. Damn you. – Senior Editor James Riswick

Relevant video clip: