Road & Track Comparison Test


Aug 28, 2022 , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Road & Track Comparison Test

Nostalgia is a strong thing. It pervades so significantly of the zeitgeist, with Television set reboots getting cranked out at an almost alarming amount, and vinyl report profits topping $1 billion for the to start with time considering the fact that 1986. Motor vehicle fans are a significantly nostalgic bunch just glance at the values of the cars and trucks Gen X and Millennials saw as icons. This cultural power has observed a quantity of terrific nameplates revived, like the Toyota Supra, or reinvigorated with an eye in direction of earlier glories, as is the case with the new Nissan Z.

Z vs. Supra is by no indicates a perennial struggle like Mustang vs. Camaro, while the 300ZX and Supra went just after the kind wanting for a rapidly, technologically state-of-the-art, sports activities-GT via the Eighties and Nineties. Currently, these two healthy the a lot more common athletics car mold: Six-cylinder engines beneath a very long hood, two seats in the middle, driven wheels at the back.

Value Comparison

This comparison test was obvious past any nostalgic connections. The Nissan Z costs $51,015 in “Effectiveness” guise, can make 400 hp and 350 lb-ft from a twin-turbo V-6 and weighs 3507 kilos. The Supra 3. commences at $52,500, makes 382 hp and 368 lb-ft from a single-turbo straight-6, and weighs 3347 lbs ..

(We’re simplifying items a bit, as the base Z charges $41,015, although it does without the restricted-slip differential, upgraded brakes, and sportier suspension tune of the Performance product. The Supra starts at $43,450, even so, that is with four-cylinder electrical power. Our Z tester was a $54,015 2023 “Proto” spec, mechanically similar to the Performance but with gold wheels and yellow inside accents. The Supra was a 2022 Quality product retailing for $57,355.)

Decision of venue was apparent, way too. Lime Rock Park is a single of America’s great road programs, quick, flowing, and surrounded by magnificent region roads that would give us the chance to totally test every car or truck. Lime Rock is also a person of the tracks exactly where the primary Datsun Z created its mark, earning a status as a person of the finest sports activities cars on sale in America. Driving a automobile that evokes the 240Z, channeling legends like Bob Sharp, Sam Posey, Paul Newman, and many many others, was irresistible.

Did anyone say something about nostalgia?

Road & Track Comparison Test

DW Burnett

Nissan Z on Keep track of

The Z exudes classic athletics-auto appeal. This new model rides on the exact same chassis as the 370Z, by itself an update of the 350Z that entered output 20 several years back, As a result, it feels old, but in a superior way.

Even though not an out-and-out monitor automobile, the Z was a joy all around Lime Rock, and impressively rapid. Editor-at-Large Travis Okulski was on hand to set lap occasions, and we adopted our typical technique where every car or truck acquired a handful of sizzling laps. The strategy is not to get the fastest time probable, but to exhibit how approachable a car or truck is. The Z posted a 1:02.603 in its 3rd traveling lap around the “basic” 1.5-mile structure of the circuit. A pretty respectable time, and a single that was not challenging to reach, thanks to its well balanced chassis, security beneath braking, and communicative controls. Okulski said the Z drives like a major Miata and anyone else agreed. You can find a reasonable little bit of overall body roll in cornering, even though the vehicle by no means feels like it is overworking the tires. That roll, merged with well-weighted steering—and a terrific steering wheel—give the driver a tangible sense of relationship. Okulski famous some mid-corner understeer in Lime Rock’s lengthy first turn, Huge Bend, nonetheless it can be managed with a slight elevate of the throttle. It truly is all beautifully cohesive, the rear faithfully subsequent the front, supplying the driver a ton of self-confidence.

Nissan equipped our tester with NISMO brake pads, which will be obtainable at sellers for $450 a established. The brakes had been a emphasize, supplying fade-totally free effectiveness throughout our observe time. Pedal experience was great, way too, with a small bit of “sneeze element” at the prime of the journey, and easy modulation. Those are excellent attributes for Lime Rock, which has only one major brake zone, at the conclusion of the front straight, where by the Z was hitting about 125 mph, and a couple of spots exactly where a dab of brake is important to scrub off velocity. The only caveats here are that the pads are fairly expensive and make an extraordinary volume of dust.

2023 nissan z performance and 2022 toyota supra

DW Burnett

The Z returns to turbocharging for the initially time because the demise of the Z32 300ZX in 2000, borrowing a 3.-liter device from Infiniti. When you first get on throttle, there’s a bit of lag, adopted by the two turbochargers spooling up very progressively and furnishing linear shipping to a tiny above 6000 rpm. (Peak electrical power is achieved at 6400 rpm, but torque drops off above 5200 rpm.) All round, it’s a extremely nice engine, if not solely exclusive, and it gives the Z major rate.

Our tester was outfitted with a manual, and we couldn’t be far more delighted. Properly, we could. The gates are not as precisely outlined as we might like, and the two Okulski and I worried about accidental 5-2 downshifts braking into switch 1. I identified the pedals to be properly-spaced for heel-and-toe, though Okulski—who has excessively very long legs—didn’t. It is considerably of a moot point, because the transmission arrives with automobile rev-matching—something Nissan pioneered—which operates intuitively. A small-change package would assistance the really feel listed here. We retained coming back to two text: “engaging” and “pleasurable.” The Z is a terrific sports activities motor vehicle, basic and very simple, a reminder of why we fell in appreciate with sporting activities automobiles in the 1st area. For the funds, a Camaro SS 1LE is potentially a greater monitor auto, but for anyone who predominantly drives on the highway and does a single or two track days a 12 months, the Z is just about great.

Toyota Supra on Keep track of

Notably, “partaking” or “enjoyment” were being not phrases made use of to describe the Supra. Quickly? Unquestionably. It defeat the Z with a 1:02.151 and we are confident it could’ve absent even a lot quicker (a Supra exam we did in 2019 for an all-out lap time saw a single change a 1:01.51 at Lime Rock). Thank the Supra’s Michelin Pilot Super Athletics, which are excellent to the Z’s Bridgestone S007s, the 8-velocity automatic in this take a look at vehicle, and a higher roll stiffness. Sad to say, we’re however about a month out from testing the new, manual Supra, generating this a a little lopsided struggle.

The experience just is not as fulfilling. Velocity comes much less difficult in the Supra, though there is a nagging perception that the automobile is extra keen to bite you. The rear end is far as well comfortable, wandering underneath braking, struggling with the prodigious output of the BMW straight-6, and usually unable to hold up with the incredibly sharp front conclusion. In contrast to with the Z, wherever you sometimes have to believe about the fronts washing out, the Supra calls for concentration on the rear.

It is not all poor, of study course. The engine is the emphasize, far smoother than the Z’s V-6 and with a great deal better throttle reaction even with only obtaining 1 turbo. You can find a lot extra very low-stop torque, as well, and the straight-6 pulls more challenging to its 7000-rpm redline. Most of the time, the ZF eight-velocity automatic works as seamlessly as you’d be expecting, though Okulski and Electronic Director Aaron Brown found that it often denied downshifts.

Apparently, we all felt the Supra wouldn’t be as engaging as the Z even if it had a manual. At least not with out some meaningful chassis tweaks. The Toyota retains you at arm’s size, with lifeless steering, and not significantly far more experience by way of the seat of your pants either. It’s faster in palms of all experience concentrations, just not enjoyable.

“The Supra feels like a newer auto,” Okulski claimed. “Which is to say, it has all the negative traits of new vehicles and all the good qualities. It truly is received a quicker gearbox, a considerably better, additional responsive motor, superior tires, a much more related front conclusion, and it also feels like it was built only in pursuit of lap occasions, not producing the driver sense associated in the process.”

On the Street

Out on the road, it was a similar tale. The Z’s playfulness stood out, and the softer set up started to make even extra perception. It breathes greater with the highway and engages at reduce speeds, even if it can be easily able of pace that could charitably be described as “extralegal.” Outside the keep track of, in the lovely countryside at Connecticut’s north westerly border with New York, the Z feels at house. At street speeds, the turbo lag and the relative imprecision of the gearbox turn out to be less apparent. It is, on the other hand, obvious that the Z is a considerably older automobile within, with a ton of low-cost switchgear carried about from the 370Z and other Nissan solutions. It is a important evil, as Nissan isn’t going to have the improvement price range to establish a athletics vehicle from the floor up. It is also conveniently forgivable due to the fact the significant stuff—seats, steering wheel, transmission, pedals—is all beautiful. The gauge cluster is specifically great and gimmick-totally free, with a nice huge tach in the middle and legible gauges for temperatures and pressures. Just what you have to have in a sporting activities auto. Reward points go to the 3 auxiliary gauges on the dashboard, the very best of which is the really uncommon turbo velocity sensor, a knock-on profit of Nissan’s use of velocity sensors on the turbine shafts.

The Supra’s BMW roots are noticeable in the cabin, and it feels much a lot more lavish than the Z. There is a slickness and polish Nissan simply can’t match. In some strategies, the Supra is the improved every day driver, the preferable motor vehicle to be in when you might be puttering all around city, clicking off miles on the freeway, sitting in visitors, listening to a podcast. Nevertheless, when you happen to be hoping to have pleasurable, the Supra does not supply. It’s a auto that leaves the driver sensation cold and distant, and the suspension tuning just isn’t appropriate. That rear end skips around bumps and imperfections, and it truly is a lot harder to get into a stream with the highway surface area beneath.

In a excellent environment, you would have the Z’s chassis and amazing exterior and the Supra’s motor and interior. We you should not reside in a fantastic entire world, so the Z remains the finest alternative. Right after all, this is a sporting activities automobile. We really don’t obtain sports autos on interior trim we get them for the pleasure they provide to our lives.

Which brings us back neatly to nostalgia. In much more than just appears to be, the Z evokes the spirit of the athletics automobile greats, its predecessors amongst them. It truly is enjoyable for fun’s sake, the uncommon present day automobile that certainly engages the senses like a typical.

It is anything of a triumph from Nissan. Its track record in excess of the final handful of yrs has been lackluster. We ended up ready for disappointment, but the Z life up to its assure. It can be just one of the best Nissans considering the fact that the GT-R. Inspite of becoming produced with theoretically improved, extra present day factors, the Supra’s total is fewer than the sum. I’d like to consider there is a excellent sports automobile in there someplace, and probably the 2023 edition will be particularly that. For now, if you want a wonderful Toyota-badged sporting activities auto, buy a GR86.

For the nostalgia obsessed, the option is noticeable.